Observe: On The Water is reader-supported. While you purchase by hyperlinks on our web site, we could earn an affiliate fee.
The grey-white frost of Eddie’s breath remained suspended in a form of sluggish animation, projected in opposition to the inky backdrop of the November evening, a lot in order that for a second I assumed he was vaping. Even from 10 ft away, I heard the audible thump of his rod. Braid tore from the road curler as if he’d clipped the Bomber Lengthy A to the again of a passing SUV. I had simply slipped into the water and the ideas of my fingers had been rapidly going numb. All of the sudden, the screaming drag stopped, as if somebody hit mute proper as this scene approached a climactic level within the plot. The fish spit the hook and as Eddie’s neck swiveled in my path, I seen his eyes had been as broad as boiled eggs, not as a result of he had misplaced the primary fish of the evening, however as a result of he realized that I wasn’t a liar. “There are giants right here.” It was mid- November and for the primary time in three winters, I requested a pal to affix one in all my secret missions. Eddie was my accomplice within the surf and had shared a few of his most treasured spots with me, so I assumed it was solely proper to ask him. Plus, it may be lonely and boring on the market within the chilly when the fishing is sluggish, which is commonly. He confirmed reasonable curiosity at first and admitted that he didn’t usually do a lot “holdover fishing.” I assured him that this may be completely different, and he agreed to fulfill me.
On the time, Eddie didn’t notice that I’d introduced him to an space on that evening for very particular causes. Earlier that day, he requested “isn’t it going to be freezing tonight?” The reply was sure, and that was precisely why we wanted to go, to catch what I’ve come to name “the cold-snap chunk.”The primary actual chilly snap in November usually sends our resident fish into hyper drive. After three years of experiencing this phenomenon, I imagine the fish sense that winter is coming and aggressively feed in anticipation of the brutal months forward. Shortly after this feeding occasion, which may last as long as per week, the fish change conduct and act extra like sluggish holdovers, sticking to backside, slowing their metabolisms, and feeding occasionally. By early December, patterns I swear I had uncovered evaporate into the ether and it’s again to grinding for weeks at a time with only a few—or typically no—bites.
This primary chilly snap, coupled with the thinning of pure bait, represents a singular alternative for these of us who scour the backwaters for striped bass that move on the migration and name our native estuaries house. When I’m fortunate sufficient to search out the fish on the proper stage of the tide and decipher what they need to eat, I usually get pleasure from a few of the finest fishing of the season. Final yr, I used to be blissful to lastly share this occasion with a pal who acquired to witness and partake alongside me. Part of me had nearly forgotten how particular it was, however seeing his disbelief after nearly getting his shoulder dislocated on an enormous fish in sub-32-degree temps was all it took to remind me how fortunate I’m to do what I like 12 months a yr.
Shortly after Eddie misplaced his fish, I went tight. After a decent struggle, I finally acquired the fish to roll on her facet and we acquired the primary glimpse. It was a stout 25-pound-class fish and Eddie couldn’t imagine it. If I recall appropriately, he merely yelled “Dude!” or “Bro!” No matter he stated was drenched in monotone bewilderment. What he meant was, “This is senseless!” We had simply spent the earlier month chasing the final of the schoolies because the Fall migration waned in our native waters. On numerous nights, we drove from Massachusetts to Rhode Island simply to catch a number of small fish, or usually no fish. All of the sudden, this secret winter wonderland revealed itself, as if I had simply lifted a magic curtain that exposed a form of Striped Bass Narnia.
I defined that even bigger fish had been within the space so we wanted to maintain casting because it was clear that they had been fired up. I knew that we had the chilly snap working to our benefit, and it was only a matter of time earlier than we related with one thing larger. The previous couple of winters had taught me that 35-pound fish had been current in Massachusetts waters, a few of which I’ve caught into the primary week in January after going weeks and not using a chunk. Different fish that I think had been even bigger had gotten away—bent hooks and demolished plugs had been widespread occurrences at a number of of my favourite winter spots.
I took off the Bomber minnow plug I used to be utilizing and clipped on a Tremendous Snax weightless gentle plastic. As I retrieved at a sluggish/medium pace, I acquired completely smoked by an even bigger fish that instantly started to run. I fish with my drag set extraordinarily tight, so Eddie knew it was a superb fish on account of the prolonged runs it was taking. Even after I acquired the fish in entrance of me and grabbed my 60-pound chief, she didn’t cease preventing. Chilly water exploded into the November evening as her tail slapped the floor, propelling her in a round sample. When she lastly settled, I acquired my grip on her backside lip and held her up for Eddie to see. She was someplace within the 28- to 30-pound vary, chunky, and had a stupendous blue-white hue. These fish weren’t merely surviving within the frigid estuaries all yr—they had been wholesome and thriving.
I landed a number of extra fish within the mid- to upper-20-pound vary and Eddie was variety sufficient to snap a number of pictures for me, however I may inform he was decided to land one earlier than the evening ended. He had connected at the very least three extra occasions since shedding the primary fish however hadn’t efficiently landed one. Every of his hookups started with heart-pounding drag screams and led to silence. Eddie is an skilled surfcaster, having landed fish as much as 51 kilos, so this wasn’t a matter of ability. Trying again, I don’t assume he was mentally ready for striped bass mayhem to unfold in 30-degree climate. The primary time you join with a big fish within the context of a frigid panorama, it doesn’t make sense and may catch you off guard as a result of it goes in opposition to so lots of the extensively accepted “guidelines” of fish conduct associated to water temp, depth and “water high quality.” That, coupled with frozen fingers and impaired dexterity, actually makes for difficult fishing.
My final fish of the evening was about 30 kilos, and after releasing her, I took a break. Eddie continued, and simply as we had been about to depart, he hooked into one other fish. We each sighed in aid as he introduced the fish to his ft. It ended up being the smallest fish of the evening, but nonetheless over 20 kilos.A number of nights later, he returned on his personal and despatched me an image at 1 a.m. of him holding an absolute monster, larger than any we had caught a number of nights earlier. I laughed out loud after I acquired the textual content as a result of he was carrying a kind of Russian-style, furry winter hats within the picture, one thing I assume he procured particularly for his return to our winter wonderland. He went again for redemption, made the suitable changes based mostly on his earlier struggles, and landed his first, however actually not his final, winter big. I wanted I may have been there, however I felt a way of aid that I had somebody I may share these tales with. Secrecy is important to preserving the areas that maintain bigger fish, however I had fished these spots alone for therefore lengthy that I’d skilled the magic in a vacuum, so to talk. It was like successful the lottery and having to maintain it a secret. As soon as I shared this phenomenon with Eddie, I felt renewed.It’s at all times a raffle in storytelling if you begin with the ending and work your manner again to the start, nevertheless it’s price explaining what led to my chilly snap discovery.
As I waded into the trenches of my early 40s, I began getting small glimpses of the way by which my age and perspective has the potential to deliver new items to the desk in trade for younger items (like good eyesight) which have fallen to the wayside. For one, I’m rather less encumbered by the nice and cozy cloak of pondering that I do know every little thing. Actually, the deeper I descend into this surfcasting rabbit gap, the extra I notice I nonetheless don’t know a lot in any respect. Or extra precisely, I’ve come to phrases with what’s extra possible true. What I find out about striped bass solely serves me now and again, or for fleeting intervals, till new truths, or higher truths, unravel, bringing me on a non-linear fishing journey which may be perceived by others as progress.
This fluid, ever-evolving mind-set about surfcasting and fish conduct has a number of benefits. First, it’s allowed me to ponder what loopy, unlikely, and seemingly unimaginable issues are achievable on this sport. Releasing myself of any inflexible, absolute truths has afforded me the luxurious of daydreaming about having the ability to catch giant fish in native waters 12 months a yr, one thing that the youthful me thought was unimaginable. Refusing to tie myself to the anchor of previous classes allowed me to press by some daunting thresholds of “failure.” It wasn’t at all times simple, however I did my finest to view my winter outings as exploratory as a substitute of by the binary lens of “profitable” or “unsuccessful.” On the opposite facet of these thresholds, I skilled a few of the most memorable nights of my life.
A number of years again, feeling depressed that winter had arrived, I requested myself a easy query. What if I preserve fishing? What if I don’t put the gear away and proceed fishing all winter?
It’s no secret that many estuaries entice “holdover” stripers that keep in native waters all season. I wrote an article on the right way to goal “holdovers” within the 2022 On The Water Angler’s Almanac. The article was largely a how-to information on concentrating on small fish all through the winter by cutting down sort out and utilizing the appropriate ways. Shortly after that publication, I set my sights on a brand new purpose. I puzzled if bigger fish, within the 20- to 30-pound vary, stay in Massachusetts all yr lengthy. After a number of years of scouring the backwaters from Cape Cod to north of Boston, it seems they do, and many them.
I now imagine, by direct expertise and from credible contacts in different states, that the resident inhabitants of enormous striped bass in each state from New Jersey to Maine is astronomically bigger than anybody beforehand understood.
For readers in search of a simple path to catching them, I remorse to say that there’s nothing simple about winter fishing. I’ve, nonetheless, discovered a sample that has provided me a handful of tides that I’ll always remember. As winter approaches, many surfcasters are keen to enterprise out on hotter nights, partly for their very own consolation, but in addition as a result of they imagine hotter climate results in extra energetic fish. I additionally believed this for years till many frozen nights revealed the magical results of the Chilly Snap on fish conduct. I used to be hesitant to seek advice from it as a sample after the second yr, however now, as I strategy the fourth consecutive yr of testing this sample, I’m snug that it holds true. After all, I’m effectively conscious that what I find out about striped bass will proceed to evolve, remodel, dissolve, or in any other case shock me, again and again, till the very finish.